The Cubs' big trade for Kyle Tucker has left many wondering if they truly understand what Tucker wants as a free agent. In a move that granted the Cubs an exclusive negotiating window, they now face the challenge of convincing Tucker to stay.
While it might have been beneficial for Tucker to explore his options and for the Cubs to avoid bidding against themselves, the one-year partnership has revealed a certain detachment between both parties.
Tucker's calm demeanor and patience, both in the batter's box and as a free agent, contrast with Jed Hoyer's disciplined and unsentimental approach. Hoyer's style, honed over 14 seasons as a top executive, prioritizes process over emotions, which can be a double-edged sword in the free-agent market.
Despite a quiet second half plagued by injuries, Tucker has already attracted interest from other teams. His hometown team, the Tampa Bay Rays, with their new ownership group, and the Philadelphia Phillies, eager for a roster makeover, are potential suitors. Even the New York Yankees have listed Tucker as a top priority for their 2026 World Series run.
Hoyer, however, maintains a pragmatic stance, emphasizing the importance of player valuation and the organization's needs. He hasn't begun serious budget discussions for next year and is cautious about the uncertainty surrounding the expiration of the collective bargaining agreement in 2026.
With only Dansby Swanson on a fully guaranteed contract beyond 2026, the Cubs face a challenging decision. As Hoyer puts it, "It's something we have to consider. We don't know what's going to happen. There's real uncertainty there."
As the Cubs reflect on their season, they must decide if Tucker's impact was enough to warrant a long-term commitment. Will they be able to convince Tucker to stay, or will he explore the market and potentially find a better fit elsewhere?
The Cubs' future hangs in the balance, and only time will tell if they can secure Tucker's services for the long haul.
